"If you're going to buy - buy from us! If you're going to sell - sell to us!
Family owned & Operated for Over 30 Years! We BUY, SELL & TRADE jewelry, coins, antiques, collectibles and more at a fraction of prices found in traditional stores. Mark began the business by buying antiques, gold, silver and coins in the 1980’s. In 1989 American Antiques and Jewelry was established at 1049 W. Mason Street. Since then our business has flourished into Northeastern Wisconsin’s largest used and estate jewelry reseller. With over 100 years of combined experience, our team provides uncompromising and personal customer service you won’t find anywhere else. From fashion and costume jewelry to sterling silver, vintage treasures and diamond engagement sets we have something at every price point and that fits any budget. We are your one-stop shop for coins and currency and invite you to have a current collection assessed or add something new. Our showroom of fine antiques, sports memorabilia and military collectibles refreshes daily – you never know what you’ll find.
"If you are not family you become family."
We have the certifications, skills and expertise to assist you in buying, selling or trading. Let us welcome you to our family and exceed your expectations.Stop in and meet the friendly, kind and humorous people (and our canine celebrity - Stella) you've seen in our comical and quirky commercials.
Don't take our word for it... hear what our customers have to say about us:
-
"Great customer service and selection of jewelry! Very pleased with my purchases!"
-
"Love this place! I've bought a number of vintage jewelry pieces and have wanted sooo many more."
-
"Love them they are the nicest jewelers and super helpful."
-
"Great customer service and just a very cool place to check out! Thanks for your help Therese!"
-
"Awesome selection of beautiful jewelry for great prices, and not pushy like jewelry stores. Also, super knowledgeable and friendly staff!"
-
"My late fiance's mother sent me a USMC pendant of my fiance. The personnel at American Antiques and Jewelry were friendly and helpful. They cleaned up the pendant for free, helped me find a chain. assembled it and gave me a $5 discount. What an awesome business. I will definitely be back. Thank you American Antiques and Jewelry :) "
-
"Gorgeous rings and jewelry for half the price! Mark and his team treated me well and helped me find what I was looking for. I'll be back! You should try it out for yourself!"
-
"Love this place! Excellent people willing to help you with anything."
-
"Such a great selection of items and at such a great price, what more could you ask for you say. Oh a better staff no not anywhere. Everyone is so friendly and knowledgeable my 5 year old daughter didn't want to leave. I love the earrings!!"
-
"My boyfriend and I stopped in at American Antiques and Jewelry a few weeks ago and love it. So many treasures to choose from! Therese is an awesome salesperson to work with! Congratulations on 25 years! And thanks for the $25.00 gift certificate that I won! See you soon!"
-
"One day I stopped in to see what this store was all about. Well I found a great group of people and tons of quality jewelry. I bought a few pieces and have made it my personal jewelry store. They pay top dollar for gold and sell top rated gems. Thanks American you are on top of my lists."
-
"The only place I (and my family) go for jewelry!! I am a third generation American Antiques buyer. Great store, great prices and GREAT people!!"
-
"Great owners great employees"
-
"Great selection of unique rings. Found a perfect antique one-of-a-kind ring that made for an incredible proposal. Definitely hope to do business with them in the future!"